commercetools vs Adobe Commerce: What to Select?

When it comes to building a robust E-commerce solution, choosing the right platform is crucial. Among all the existing software solutions for online commerce, two popular options, commercetools and Adobe Commerce, offer distinct advantages tailored to varying business needs, and understanding their differences can help you make an informed decision.

In this article, we'll examine both platforms' key features, strengths, and ideal use cases to help you determine which is the best fit for your business.

Adobe Commerce vs commercetools: A Quick Overview

Commercetools and Adobe Commerce represent two powerful solutions in the field of E-commerce, each catering to distinct business needs.

Commercetools is renowned for its modern, API-first, headless architecture, which empowers businesses to design highly customized and scalable online stores. Its modular microservices support seamless integrations and rapid innovation, making it ideal for businesses prioritizing flexibility and omnichannel strategies.

Adobe Commerce (formerly Magento) is a robust, feature-rich, all-in-one platform. It aims to simplify various E-commerce processes with built-in tools for content management, marketing, analytics, and SEO, providing a comprehensive solution for businesses seeking convenience and efficiency. Adobe Commerce also offers limitless customization opportunities through its extensive marketplace of extensions and strong developer community.

Both solutions provide businesses with exceptional features for creating E-commerce websites. Still, the key difference is in the architecture. While Adobe Commerce is more suited for businesses seeking a unified, feature-rich platform that requires minimal customization to get started, commercetools excels in flexibility and scalability through its headless architecture. Choosing between the two depends on your business's need for innovation versus convenience.

Step-By-Step Comparison

When evaluating E-commerce platforms, understanding how they differ across various critical points is key to choosing the right solution. Below is a direct comparison of Commercetools and Adobe Commerce based on essential criteria.

Architecture

commercetools

Commercetools adheres to the MACH principle (Microservices-based, API-first, Cloud-native, and Headless), offering unparalleled flexibility, scalability, and future-proof integrations. This modular approach enables businesses to tailor every aspect of their E-commerce ecosystem.

Adobe Commerce

Adobe Commerce employs a monolithic architecture, providing a unified system with tightly integrated features and functionalities. It is compliant with microservices, available as a Cloud-based version, and follows Headless commerce principles. Although Adobe Commerce is comprehensive, it can be less flexible for businesses seeking independent module updates or customizations.

Ease of use

commercetools

Designed for tech-savvy users and developers, commercetools requires technical expertise to manage APIs and customize features. While powerful, it might present a learning curve for non-technical teams.

Adobe Commerce

Intuitive interface and user-friendly tools are the reasons why businesses of all technical levels migrate to Adobe Commerce. Pre-built templates and an extensive library of plugins simplify the setup and management process.

Checkout process

commercetools

The headless architecture of commercetools enables businesses to design fully customized and streamlined checkout processes across multiple channels, offering a consistent user experience.

Adobe Commerce

Adobe Commerce provides efficient and reliable out-of-the-box checkout options. However, its flexibility for customizing the checkout experience may seem limited compared to Commercetools.

Security

commercetools

As a cloud-native platform, commercetools provides robust security measures, including compliance with GDPR and PCI DSS standards. Regular updates help to address vulnerabilities promptly.

Adobe Commerce

Adobe Commerce offers advanced security features such as two-factor authentication and extensive monitoring tools. Security patches are released regularly but require manual implementation.

Performance

commercetools

Commercetools excels in performance due to its microservices architecture. Businesses benefit from faster load times and the ability to scale without impacting system performance.

Adobe Commerce

Adobe Commerce's performance can vary depending on server resources and configurations. Optimizations like caching can enhance speed, but resource-heavy features might impact performance.

Product management

commercetools

Commercetools offers advanced product management capabilities, supporting multi-region and multi-channel catalogs. Its flexibility suits businesses with complex inventories.

Adobe Commerce

Adobe Commerce features a comprehensive product management system that easily handles complex catalogs. It's well-suited for businesses managing fewer inventories.

Customizations

commercetools

Commercetools enables extensive customizations through its API-first approach. Businesses can adapt every element of their E-commerce platform to their unique needs.

Adobe Commerce

While customizable, its monolithic architecture makes complex changes more challenging and time-consuming compared to commercetools.

Developers' community

commercetools

Commercetools boasts a growing developer community focusing on developing innovative, headless commerce solutions.

Adobe Commerce

Adobe Commerce has a long-established, active developer community that provides quality E-commerce development services, offers detailed documentation, participates in various forum discussions, and crafts custom plugins for enhanced functionality.

Adobe Commerce vs commercetools: Pricing Comparison

Feature	commercetools	Adobe Commerce (Cloud)	Adobe Commerce (On-Premise)
Pricing model	Subscription-based, depends on usage and GMV (Gross Merchandise Volume)	Subscription-based, depends on GMV	License-based with optional hosting fees
License costs	~$50,000 annually (based on GMV and API usage)	Range from $40,000 to $190 000 annually (based on GMV and features)	Range from $22,000 to $120 000 annually (depending on GMV and features)
Maintenance	Included updates and support	Automatic updates, 24/7 support included in the license fee	Manual management, requiring dedicated staff or outside help, $1.5K - $10K/year
Hosting	Included (Cloud-native platform)	Included (Adobe-managed Cloud)	Not included (it is necessary to choose hosting from a third-party)
Additional costs	API consumption fees, custom integrations	Extensions, scaling resources	Hosting, security patches, extensions

What Is the Right Platform for My Business?

Selecting the best E-commerce platform for your business hinges on your unique needs, goals, and operational scale. Consider the following points to make the correct decision:

Flexibility and scalability

If your business requires dynamic scaling, multi-channel selling, or innovative customer experiences, commercetools might be the better fit. Its MACH-based architecture ensures flexibility and adaptability, making it ideal for businesses anticipating rapid growth or complex integrations.

All-in-one simplicity

For businesses seeking a ready-to-use platform with robust features out of the box, Adobe Commerce is an excellent option. It offers a more traditional structure, extensive community support, and ease of deployment, especially for small to medium-sized businesses.

Budget constraints

While both platforms require investment, Adobe Commerce offers more predictable and transparent pricing for businesses with limited GMV. Commercetools, on the other hand, suits businesses with more significant GMV and specific customization needs, where its API-first approach provides long-term ROI.

Technical resources

Consider your team's technical expertise. Commercetools demands significant developer involvement for implementation and maintenance, while Adobe Commerce offers a user-friendly interface with manageable customization for non-technical users.

Key Takeaways

When comparing commercetools and Adobe Commerce, we conclude that both platforms stand out as robust E-commerce solutions, but they cater to different business needs:

1. Commercetools offers unmatched flexibility, ideal for large-scale enterprises focusing on scalability, innovation, and omnichannel strategies.
2. Adobe Commerce provides an all-in-one solution with a monolithic architecture, making it a solid choice for businesses seeking a comprehensive, easy-to-deploy platform with transparent costs.
3. Budget, technical expertise, and business goals are critical in selecting the right platform.

More from Emerline

Emerline's experts constantly explore various E-commerce solutions to help you find the most suitable one for your business needs. Discover our articles with detailed insights and make an informed decision:

• Magento vs Shopify
• BigCommerce vs Magento
• WordPress vs Magento
• Magento vs WooCommerce